Supreme Court Ruling Allows Flexibility In Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

June 26th, 2010 by Reed Allmand

Supreme Court Allows Flexibility In Chapter 13The Supreme Court ruled that bankruptcy courts can now account for changes in a debtor’s income or expenses when calculating projected disposable income.  The deciding case involved Stephanie Kay Lanning, a debtor who filed Chapter 13 bankruptcy and agreed to pay off $36,700 in unsecured debt in three years.  The bankruptcy trustee objected to the debtor’s proposed bankruptcy plan because the debtor’s projected disposable income was not based on her last six months of income, which included a one-time buyout from her former employer.  But the debtor argued that by using the prior six months to calculate her projected disposable income, it would falsely inflate her future income by $149 per month.

Eventually the bankruptcy court approved the debtor’s plan to pay $144 per month; but required her to pay that over a five year plan instead of a 3 year plan.   The Supreme Court recently sided with the debtor saying that she is in fact correct, that her one-time buyout should not be included and that she could account for changes in income and expenses when calculating her projected disposable income.

Justice Samuel Alito said the term “projected” is a strong indicator that Congress meant for other factors to be considered besides past income.  “While a projection takes past events into account, adjustments are often made based on other factors that may affect the final outcome,” he wrote. He added that lawmakers have rarely used “projected” to mean “simple multiplication.” For that, they use the term “multiplied.”
In light of this historical practice, we would expect that, had Congress intended for ‘projected’ to carry a specialized – and indeed, unusual – meaning in Chapter 13, Congress would have said so expressly,” Alito wrote. 

 

 

Fortunately for future Chapter 13 bankruptcy debtors this Supreme Court ruling will force bankruptcy courts to take into account changes in income and expenses when calculating debtors’ projected disposable income.

About Reed Allmand

Website

Allmand's vision is rooted in his own financially precarious childhood in Abilene "My father always had difficulty holding a job and supporting our family, so after my parents divorced when I was 12, my sister and I got jobs to help make ends meet," he recalls. "I remember what it felt like as a child to worry that our car would be repossessed or home foreclosed on."

View all posts by Reed Allmand

Subscribe

Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

    FAQ

    Why do I need to submit a new wage order when I modify my plan

    When we modify your bankruptcy plan we are changing your plan payments. This means that we have to get with your employer and change the terms and amount of your wage order. The only way we can do that is by filling out a new wage order form.  

    Learn More
    What happens if the stay terminates on my home?

    If the bankruptcy stay terminates on your home that means that even though your in bankruptcy, your creditor can pursue all there legal remedies they can pursue if you were not in bankruptcy. This includes foreclosure, and having your house sold and evicting you from your house.

    Learn More

    Find Location

    map
    • Dallas Bankruptcy

      5646 Milton Street, Ste. 120 Dallas, Texas 75206
    • Fort Worth Bankruptcy

      5601 Bridge Street # 300 Ft Worth, TX 76112

    Meet Our Clients